June 25, 2017

To Own Or Rent? Proceed Wisely

Keep Your Family Happy

Keep Your Family Happy

Home ownership is the American ideal. But there are good and valid instances in which renting is a better alternative. Look at them carefully before taking the leap into a mortgage.

If You Make Frequent Moves

If you know that your job is going to require that you relocate every few years, or if a bit of “wanderlust” is part of your makeup, you’d be foolish to be burdened with home ownership everywhere you went. Home purchases and sales involve costs, with fees on both sides. Even in a positive market where property values intend to increase, you aren’t likely to break even.

When A House Payment Would Break You

It isn’t just the monthly payment. There tends to be more out-of-pocket expenses with home ownership. Maintenance and repairs, for instance. When debating the factors, add about a thousand dollars a year to the mortgage money for such costs. Best to leave those to another owner while you pay a set rent if things are looking tight.

If you are looking at homes, notice that some of them are in serious disrepair, probably from just this circumstance. The owners can afford the payment, but not the upkeep. Assume that this could happen to you too, if the margins are too skimpy. Maybe, like some home purchasers, you believe you can take care of upkeep and repairs yourself, but if the demands get beyond your capacities, you’ll end up paying a contractor. Being house poor is hardly a desirable offset for the perceived blessings of owning.

What Your Area Offers

If in your neighborhood a home typically sells for $300,000, with a monthly payment of $1,800, but rentals can be had for $1,000 a month, the math isn’t hard to do.

Unless you can easily manage the $1,800, the rental seems the better option. What you lose in such a scenario is the tax advantage that a mortgage offers. But the $800-per-month savings in rental payments goes a long way toward offsetting that advantage. And you needn’t look at the additional costs of maintenance and repairs, which amounts to even more savings.

Making Major Life Changes

A personal financial crunch, divorce, being widowed, relocation, starting a new job — these and many other unexpected life events are all good reasons that you may need to rethink ownership vs. renting, at least temporarily. Any situation that creates a new reality for you should demand such a rethink. In any major life upheaval, renting could provide the flexibility you need before things settle into that new reality. Not being tied to a mortgage could help you safely bridge gaps when things don’t go as you had thought they would.

If owning a home is your dream, go for it. But remember that renting is a good option until the dream comes true.

About Twila Van Leer

Journalist/writer for more than 50 years. Pulitzer Prize nominee, 1983 for coverage of the first permanent artificial heart. More than 50 national, regional, local awards for news writing. Main writer for a memorial book for Deseret News' 150 th anniversary and for a book recounting the 1997 re-enactment of the pioneer trek from Omaha to Salt Lake City. Co-writer and editor of "True Valor," a book on the history of the artificial heart. Author of the book, Life Is Just A Bowl Of Kumquats, a wonderful story of a house wife and her trials with raising a large family.